Savage X Fenty was heavily criticized in Remake's 2022 Fashion Accountability Report for extremely poor ethical practices. The report highlighted that the company received one of the lowest scores, with zeros in traceability, commercial practices, environmental justice, and raw materials categories. Additionally, the report noted failures in paying living wages to indirect employees such as garment and supply chain workers, models, and drivers.

The Fashion Revolution Transparency Index 2023 report reveals that Savage X Fenty is one of 18 major fashion brands that received a 0% score, indicating a lack of disclosure regarding worker rights, wages, and sustainable practices.

A Remake article criticizes Savage X Fenty for severely lacking in ethical business practices, highlighting its failure to implement basic worker safeguards, a Supplier Code of Conduct, and robust social and environmental disclosures. The report underscores that these deficiencies, particularly affecting its predominantly female supply chain, contribute to the company's low accountability scores compared to industry peers.

A global advocacy report by Remake highlighted that Savage X Fenty scored only 4 out of 150 points on ethical practices. The report cites inadequate social and environmental disclosures, a lack of a Supplier Code of Conduct to oversee labor standards, reliance on unsustainable oil-based synthetic materials, and a £1 million fine for allegedly defrauding consumers, raising significant concerns about the company’s business practices.

Johnny Depp made a brief appearance in Rihanna’s Savage X Fenty show on November 9, 2022, which sparked backlash from progressive artists and fans. Notable figures, including Olly Alexander and Years & Years, expressed disapproval and indicated their intent to boycott the brand, raising concerns over the company's alignment with its progressive values.